After I read the relevant section of Duffy's book, I set it aside for a day and read one of Simon Millar's three books: Kolin 1757, Rossbach and Leuthen 1757, and Zorndorf 1758. The books are Osprey Campaign Series Numbers 91, 113 and 125, respectively.
We'll discuss these particular battles, and the tactics involved, in a separate post, but for now I'd like to discuss the Osprey books themselves. I find them quite useful, especially as a starting point for further research. I got all three titles through the Inter-Library Loan system, so I only have them for a brief time, but I would consider buying all three.
What I Liked:
1) These books are a pretty easy read. If I skip the illustrations and the captions, I can breeze through the main text in about four hours. When I go back and read the captions and the maps, it's another summary of the text, in a more visual format. That helps with the retention.
2) They have very nice full-color two-page spreads, of action scenes from the battle, complete with numbers and captions on the overleaf, detailing the finer points of the research. They are all done by Adam Hook, who does a fine job conveying a sense of the scale, the setting and the mood of the action. There are three such "double-spreads" in each of the volumes, and all are well in the tradition of Osprey action tableau.
3) The campaign maps are reasonably close to the relevant text, are fairly well colored, and very nicely drawn showing the terrain and major towns of the wider theaters as well as the local areas near the final battle sites. The text on the legend is tiny, and the pages are shiny. I recommend daylight for the maps and the illustrations, while text can be done by electric light. More on that with the Cons.
4) They're short, they're colorful, they're focused on one (or two) battle(s) and the surrounding campaign, they give just enough information on a few of the leaders and a few of the units and the overall flavor of the period to really serve to induce the reader to wider research, and they provide a nice bibliography of the "accepted" "recommended" generally English-language sources, with enough prints after the "well known" "expert" artists. In short, I would say worth the 20 bucks.
Glitches That Are Really Features:
1) As above, reading the text is easy on the eyes. Once through for the narrative, then again by daylight for the illos helped my old eyes, and hopefully helped my muddled memory.
2) The art that isn't part of the big spreads can be... small... black and white... a print... probably fairly common, once you do the research... somewhat muddy... underwhelming by electric light. Again, a second read-through in full daylight does the trick.
3) We've spoken about the campaign maps, what about the "3D" "bird's-eye view" maps, and the regular battle maps? Well, here's the rub about the illos and maps reading separately from the text.
Battle maps work best for me when I flip back and forth, from the maps to the narrative, from the narrative back to the map. In a big book like the Duffy book, there are less maps per battle, because each is trying to contain the whole day in one or two maps.
Here there are six or eight maps per battle (something like three of the birds-eye and three of the standard style per major battle). So while I'm trying to read the narrative, I'm also looking for the correct unit on the correct map, without trying to get distracted by the beauty of the map itself, and all that tiny, tiny text detailing the day by the half-hour.
Again, going back the next day, and just poring over the maps, in and of themselves, in a nice bright light relieves my anxiety that I am somehow missing important details of the story and affected units.
4) There are those who consider Osprey books to be Cliff Notes for wargamers, and I suppose they may be right, but I don't find that to be such a bad thing. These three copies have to go back to the library, but the titles get added to the Longer List of Additional Material, as well as the Relevant Osprey list.
Really, for anyone interested in Linear Warfare and Grand Tactics in the 18th Century, and is looking for useful diagrams of units in formation and the movements of those units over the course of a campaign and throughout a day of battle, these are very useful volumes, and I look forward to adding them to the collection and reading them again.
Also, they make a nice summation of the state of the Prussian army at the start of the war, throughout the first couple of years, and of their abilities to perform some of the more complicated maneuvers required by their commander, the always interesting and often innovative Frederick the Great.
 |
| Prussian and Austrian cavalry meet at Leuthen. |
No comments:
Post a Comment